Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision
Previous revision
Next revisionBoth sides next revision
open_sauces_errata [2010-07-20 10:31] alkanopen_sauces_errata [2010-09-08 16:39] 83.101.5.51
Line 7: Line 7:
  
 === draft #18 (aka open_sauces.draft.20100413.pdf) === === draft #18 (aka open_sauces.draft.20100413.pdf) ===
-  * <del>pp 61. Remove subhead 'Notes' and set as notes for consistency with other articles (eg. pp41, pp86-87)</del> +  * <del>61. Remove subhead 'Notes' and set as notes for consistency with other articles (eg. pp41, pp86-87)</del> 
-  * <del>pp 55. include author name beneath title.</del>+  * <del>55. include author name beneath title.</del>
  
  
 === draft #25 (aka open_sauces.draft.20100422.pdf) === === draft #25 (aka open_sauces.draft.20100422.pdf) ===
   * changes to ingredients layout. check that amounts and names are consistent with earlier versions   * changes to ingredients layout. check that amounts and names are consistent with earlier versions
-  * pp76. recipe layout/formatting+  * <del>p 76. recipe layout/formatting</del>
  
  
 === draft #26 (aka open_sauces_draft.20100425.pdf) === === draft #26 (aka open_sauces_draft.20100425.pdf) ===
  
-  * pp 12-13. taste of brussels. if possible this page should look a bit archaic, with images from old herbaria and/or beer ads (see email for examples) +  * <del>pp 12-13. taste of brussels. if possible this page should look a bit archaic, with images from old herbaria and/or beer ads (see email for examples)</del> 
-  * pp 18-19. frills on parentheses very good on this page. background on this page could be a bit dusty (dukkah dust)+  * <del>pp 18-19. frills on parentheses very good on this page.</del> background on this page could be a bit dusty (dukkah dust)
   * <del>pp 49. change amounts in recipe to relative amounts in Stuffed Gol Gappa Balls (see email)</del>   * <del>pp 49. change amounts in recipe to relative amounts in Stuffed Gol Gappa Balls (see email)</del>
   * <del>pp 60-61. Femke didn't want any images with her text. The drawing should go with the recipe on the next page anyway.</del>   * <del>pp 60-61. Femke didn't want any images with her text. The drawing should go with the recipe on the next page anyway.</del>
   * <del>pp 60-61. needs page number</del>   * <del>pp 60-61. needs page number</del>
-  * pp 92-93. little fires: beautiful, but is it still readable? -- still "needs work"+  * <del>pp 92-93. little fires: beautiful, but is it still readable? -- still "needs work"</del>
   * <del>p 83 change "ginger soup" heading font</del>   * <del>p 83 change "ginger soup" heading font</del>
   * <del>p 87 footnote indicators in text **come after all other punctuation.** so ~</del>   * <del>p 87 footnote indicators in text **come after all other punctuation.** so ~</del>
Line 35: Line 35:
 === draft #31 === === draft #31 ===
   * document-wide. <del>//au bain marie// -> //au bain-marie//</del>   * document-wide. <del>//au bain marie// -> //au bain-marie//</del>
-  * <del>pp 4-7throughout this section, change hyphens to en dashes where appropriate</del>+  * pp 4-7 <del>throughout this section, change hyphens to en dashes where appropriate</del>
   * p 7. <del>change dots ... to elipses … (but best do a document-wide find and replace for these)</del>   * p 7. <del>change dots ... to elipses … (but best do a document-wide find and replace for these)</del>
     * <del>Rasa' -> Rasa's </del>     * <del>Rasa' -> Rasa's </del>
Line 42: Line 42:
     * heading "Note to the readers on how to get involved" could be rephrased either as "Note to readers […]" or "Note to the reader […]"     * heading "Note to the readers on how to get involved" could be rephrased either as "Note to readers […]" or "Note to the reader […]"
   * p 18. <del>correct table formatting for "Dukkah Dust" recipe ingredients</del>   * p 18. <del>correct table formatting for "Dukkah Dust" recipe ingredients</del>
-  * p 25. consider reflowing to avoid the two-line widow in paragraph 3?+  * p 25. <del>consider reflowing to avoid the two-line widow in paragraph 3?</del>
   * p 28. <del>1cm -> 1 cm</del>   * p 28. <del>1cm -> 1 cm</del>
   * p 41. <del>contuined -> continued</del>   * p 41. <del>contuined -> continued</del>
-  * pp 42-43. spacing here still seems off to me+  * pp 42-43. <del>spacing here still seems off to me</del>
   * p 47. <del>a hyphen here needs to be replaced with an en</del>   * p 47. <del>a hyphen here needs to be replaced with an en</del>
   * p 49. <del>make formatting of "Stuffed Gol Gappa Balls" ingredients section consistent (i.e. lowercase after ingredient quantities)</del>   * p 49. <del>make formatting of "Stuffed Gol Gappa Balls" ingredients section consistent (i.e. lowercase after ingredient quantities)</del>
Line 53: Line 53:
   * p 74. <del>quote attribution line has jumped into the next column!</del>   * p 74. <del>quote attribution line has jumped into the next column!</del>
  
-  *  i just noticed… the coloured tabs at page corners have no bleed. i don't know if this is intentional or not, but nor do i know why you //wouldn't// want bleed here, given their positioning. (alkan) -- not sure if i'll keep these anyway (nik) +  * <del>i just noticed… the coloured tabs at page corners have no bleed. i don't know if this is intentional or not, but nor do i know why you //wouldn't// want bleed here, given their positioning. (alkan) -- not sure if i'll keep these anyway (nik)</del> 
- +  * <del>also don't forget to make the text more legible in the "little fires" spread (and in some other places) as maja mentioned a while ago.</del>
-  * also don't forget to make the text more legible in the "little fires" spread (and in some other places) as maja mentioned a while ago.+
  
 === draft #37 (aka the big final reference shindig) === === draft #37 (aka the big final reference shindig) ===
Line 62: Line 61:
 the references not corrected below can be left as they are. the references not corrected below can be left as they are.
  
-  * p 18. Jean-Paul Bruneteau, _Tukka: Real Australian Food_ (New Holland Publishers, 1996) +  * p 18. <del>Jean-Paul Bruneteau, _Tukka: Real Australian Food_ (New Holland Publishers, 1996)</del> 
-  * p 23. William Longgood, _The Queen Must Die and Other Affairs of Bees and Men_ (W.W. Norton & Co, 1988) +  * p 23. <del>William Longgood, _The Queen Must Die and Other Affairs of Bees and Men_ (W.W. Norton & Co, 1988)</del> 
-    * Hubert Guerriat, _Etre Performant et Apiculture_ (Rucher du tilleul Editions, 1996) +    * <del>Hubert Guerriat, _Etre Performant et Apiculture_ (Rucher du tilleul Editions, 1996)</del> 
-  * p 42. Harold McGee, _On Food and Cooking_ (Hodder & Stoughton, 2004) +    * <del>Jürgen Tautz, _Phänomen Honigbiene_ (Spektrum Akademischer Verlag, 2007)</del> 
-  * p 56. [can maja supply the citation data in the right format heresince presumably it was her who quoted this obscure and esoteric dutch text ;)] +  * p 42. <del>Harold McGee, _On Food and Cooking_ (Hodder & Stoughton, 2004)</del> 
-  * p 61. H.M.S.J. [this massive and pompous acronym is kind of weird and archaic and so i think it should be left here] De Hol, _Ik kan koken: Geillustreerd handboek voor allen die willen leeren koken_ (Sijthof uitgeverij, 1931) +  * p 56. <del>[can maja supply the citation data] i've used: Ferran Adriaet al., _El Bulli 2003-2004_ (Ecco, 2006)</del> 
-    * Isabelle Beeton, _The Book of Household Management, 1836_ (http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/10136) +  * p 61. <del>H.M.S.J. [this massive and pompous acronym is kind of weird and archaic and so i think it should be left here] De Hol, _Ik kan koken: Geillustreerd handboek voor allen die willen leeren koken_ (Sijthof uitgeverij, 1931)</del> 
-    * Allen Downey, Jeffrey Elkner and Chris Meyers, _How to Think Like a Computer Scientist_ (Green Tea Press, 2002) +    * <del>Isabelle Beeton, _The Book of Household Management, 1836_ (http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/10136)</del> 
-    * Frederick P. Brooks, _The Mythical Man-Month: Essays on Software Engineering_ (Addison-Wesley, 1995) +    * <del>Allen Downey, Jeffrey Elkner and Chris Meyers, _How to Think Like a Computer Scientist_ (Green Tea Press, 2002)</del> 
-    * Henri Lefevbre, _Rhythmanalysis: Space, Time and Everyday Life_ (Translated by Stuart Elden and Gerald Moore, Continuum, 2004) +    * <del>Frederick P. Brooks, _The Mythical Man-Month: Essays on Software Engineering_ (Addison-Wesley, 1995)</del> 
-    * Luce Giard, Michel de Certeau and Pierre Mayol, _The Practice of Everyday Life: Living and Cooking_ (University of Minnesota Press, 1998) +    * <del>Henri Lefevbre, _Rhythmanalysis: Space, Time and Everyday Life_ (Translated by Stuart Elden and Gerald Moore, Continuum, 2004)</del> 
-    * Open Source Publishing: http://ospublish.constantvzw.org+    * <del>Luce Giard, Michel de Certeau and Pierre Mayol, _The Practice of Everyday Life: Living and Cooking_ (University of Minnesota Press, 1998)</del> 
 +    * <del>Open Source Publishing: http://ospublish.constantvzw.org</del> 
 + 
 +=== draft #41 === 
 +  * p 10. **Q.** is it ok for an ellipsis (for quotation elision) to follow a fullstop? i.e. "human sex hormones. … From the Middle Ages"  
 + 
 +=== Author's Proof #01 === 
 +  * <del>p 15. remove "Result" subhead at author's request"</del> 
 +  * <del>pp14-16. "FermentBrussels" -> "Ferment Brussels" inline italics</del> 
 +  * <del>p 23. missing "About" subhead</del> 
 +  * <del>p 34. replace period with comma after "The Big Fat Duck Cookbook"</del> 
 +  * <del>p 46. update urls at author's request</del> 
 +  * <del>p 53. bulleted list is wonky</del> 
 +  * <del>p 67. "goods in current circulation" -> "goods in recent circulation"</del> 
 +  * p 68. 
 +    * <del>quote -> italicize</del> correct? 
 +    * <del>'Adversely' -> 'Conversely'</del> 
 +    * <del>'It intentionally relates' -> 'It relates'</del> 
 +    * <del>'too coarsely constituted' -> 'ground too coarsely'</del> 
 +  * <del>p 87. references: replace hyphens with colons for consistency</del> 
 + 
 +  * **Q:** are you going to keep the blue highlighting for the urls? it looks kind of full-on to me. also, urls listed as references/further reading have no special formatting, but urls in the sourcing sections do. in the "further reading" section on p. 61, the styling is kind of mixed. wouldn't this be better if made consistent, i.e. //all// urls in blue? **A:** the blue strike probably won't stay, it's there to make sure we haven't missed ny inline urls. 
 +  * by the way, why don't you bite the bullet and just give the sourcing sections ragged margins??? just look at the paragraphs on p. 11 (also 37, etc.) :-/ ok.ok.ok.
  
 === still waiting... === === still waiting... ===
Line 91: Line 112:
     * the few footnotes there are now look fine. maybe consider using a numeral in sneha's (even though there's just the one footnote) to keep it consistent with bernard's article.     * the few footnotes there are now look fine. maybe consider using a numeral in sneha's (even though there's just the one footnote) to keep it consistent with bernard's article.
   * check libarynth and foam -> opensauces.cc urls   * check libarynth and foam -> opensauces.cc urls
-  * quote references. eg. "—Herbert Spencer in The Big Fat Duck Cookbook (Bloomsburry, 2008)" or "—F. Adria, J. Soler, A. Adria. El Bulli Books 2003. Rte. (El Bulli S.L., 2005)" i prefer the first.+  * <del>quote references. eg. "—Herbert Spencer in The Big Fat Duck Cookbook (Bloomsburry, 2008)" or "—F. Adria, J. Soler, A. Adria. El Bulli Books 2003. Rte. (El Bulli S.L., 2005)" i prefer the first.</del>
  
  
  • open_sauces_errata.txt
  • Last modified: 2014-07-03 16:04
  • by nik